The Sweet Trinity

(The Golden Vanity; The Golden Willow Tree; The Merry Golden Tree; Sir Walter Raleigh Sailing in the Lowlands; The Turkish Revelee; Lowlands Low)

A great favorite, numberless variants of this song exist in both England and America. In some tellings, the captain repents and the boy recovers to marry the captain's daughter. In Roll and Go, Colcord recounts a Kentucky mountaineers version, the only version she knows which attempts to explain why the cabinboy does not threaten to use his weapon against his ship:

If it wasn't for my love for your daughter and your men,
I would do unto you as I did unto them.

The cabinboy's explanation seems to have grown in popularity as it is included in many more modern versions.


Bullen shares this story:

In the early part of 1870, being then a boy of 12, I was wrecked upon the Alacranes Reef in the Bay of Campéché, Gulf of Mexico. We all got safe to land, where on a little patch of sand and rock only a few acres in extent we stayed for several days. We had no hardships and plenty of excellent food, but the chief joy to me was the long delightful evenings when tolling beneath a great tent we had rigged over our upturned long-boat and facing an enormous fire of driftwood, songs and stories were contributed by all. It was there that I learned the song set down above, every line of which is from the memory of those far-away days. I certainly have seen it in print since, but I can honestly declare that l have never read it, and as I have just written it, it comes quite fresh from my memory of 1870 as does the tune of which Mr Arnold thinks so highly.